I have nearly finished editing the fifth and possibly final draft of my novel “The Last Englishman” (see a previous post for an excerpt). So rightly I feel quite proud of myself, especially as this is my first novel. I have had some good comments and feedback from the small select band of people who have read drafts of it so far. All of which is good. But now I have come up against an unexpected problem.
I was in the pub last week and one of my friends who has read my novel was explaining how much she had enjoyed it. This is all well and good but then I come to the problem. Whenever people find out that I have written a novel they inevitably ask me “What’s it about?”. A natural question you might think.
But here’s my problem. I don’t actually want to tell them. And the reason for that is I hate spoilers. With a passion. I want them to read it and find out for themselves. But if I don’t tell them what it is about then they won’t want to read it.
Now I know you are all wondering what my book is actually about. I know, I can tell. Well, whenever anyone asks me I mutter vaguely about how it’s the story of a man alone, who is possibly the last man on Earth. Telling people this is a mistake, because then they want to know how come he is that lonely figure. What happened to everyone else? What catastrophe befell the planet? Obviously I can’t tell them that because that really would be a spoiler. You HAVE TO READ THE BOOK to find that one out.
For me one of the biggest joys in reading or watching a film is the anticipation of discovery. The twists and turns, cliffhangers and unexpected moments that make good books and films such a thrill.
This week I intend to go and see the film ‘The Cabin in the Woods’ and saw a review of it that was spot on. It explained how the film was really good (in the reviewers opinion) but made all the better if you know very little about it before you see it. It even recommended that you don’t watch the trailer. There were other reviews I avoided because they were helpfully tagged with ‘spoiler alert’. Why you would want to write a review with deliberate spoilers I have no idea?
It irks me when people discuss films I haven’t seen in front of me and unwittingly spoil it for me. Am I being sad?
I remember seeing the first ‘Alien’ film in the cinema when it first came out and not knowing anything about it. The tension was electric. The experience has stuck with me like glue ever since. Nowadays if I see a movie when I have already seen the trailer I often feel disappointed, partly because I sometimes feel I have already seen all the best bits.
Now I realise that readers and film goers need to know something about these things before they part with their hard earned cash. And I know that I will need to write some teasing blurb about my novel to entice the reader. I just feel that there ought to be some kind of balance between mystery and enticement.
Maybe I am being too precious about it. I had another experience last week that made me realise that different people enjoy things in different ways. Obvious really. I was with a friend who downloaded one of my short stories onto her iPad, while I was there. Once the story appeared on the shiny screen she did a thing I would never dream of doing. She automatically flicked to read the last page of the story. Some people, it seems, like to know the ending before they start. It doesn’t distract from their enjoyment like it might mine. Are you someone that does that?
So maybe I should be a bit more open about my book, even if it doesn’t come naturally…
What do you think?
© 2012 Simon Poore
12 thoughts on “Spoilers: how annoying are they?”
Are you sure the person actually read the last page? You might have been mistaken. Flicking to the back does not imply reading!
Flicking to the back means the chance of seeing that all important last word or phrase that might give everything away….;)
I also hate Amazon or blog reviews that contain spoilers. They’re often labelled “Spoiler Alert” but by the time you’ve read that, you’ve probably read on anyway. Two recent reviews of one of mine did this; I was irritated on behalf of anyone who, like you, prefers to find out by reading the book.
Reading reviews, I don’t want high school book reports that recount the events. I want to be told why I will or won’t like a book.
I agree…I want a small tantalising insight that intrigues me…
My impression of those who write spoilers deliberately, is they generally do so to put someone off; there’s often an agenda present, aimed at preventing others from reading the book. 1 and 2* are like that. Seldom see spoilers in 4 and 5 * reviews.
I think I know exactly what you mean. Guess I find it annoying when people tell me spoilers before I have read or watched something! Thanks for your comment…
There may be a side you’re not seeing to the ‘spoilers’ debate. Here’s an interesting story on a study that proves spoilers improve enjoyment of some of the genres you’d expect to be the most likely to need spoiler protection: http://io9.com/5829720/new-study-shows-that-knowing-spoilers-doesnt-ruin-a-story
Hmmm…not sure what I think of that, though it is interesting. Still think I prefer teasers to spoilers…thanks!
You still need to tell your potental audience something. There is a fine line between the teaser and a spoiler.
I couldn’t agree more!
I was recently considering buying a film on Amazon, when I saw the title of one of the reviews… which gave away the ending. In the TITLE! I didn’t have a chance of missing it. As Viv has pointed out above, the reviewer did this to express their own frustration with the ending, but that’s an entirely subjective viewpoint – I want a chance to be surprised and/or frustrated with the ending myself!
So yeah – agreed!
That sounds very annoying and inconsiderate! Thanks for your comment…